Should the Formula One Grand Prix Scoring System Be Changed?
After the eleventh race, in Hungary, of the 2011 Formula 1 motor racing season we've reached the month-long break before the excitement resumes in Belgium.
Did I say "excitement"? What was I thinking? I was probably still reminiscing about those seasons before 2010, before the change in the points scoring system occurred.
Yes, the F1 points system did need to be revamped, but it doesn't require a mathematical genius to realize the folly of the current scoring system:
1st: 25, 2nd: 18, 3rd: 15, 4th: 12, 5th: 10, 6th: 8, 7th: 6, 8th: 4, 9th: 2, 10th: 1.
Because Sebastian Vettel has won so many races, he is now so far ahead on points that he could sit at home and watch the next three races on TV, and still lead the championship! Where's the excitement in that? This situation harks back to those dismal days in the earlier 2000s when Formula One racing was merely processional, and many fans no longer bothered to watch the sport.
Other motor and motorcycle racing events use what must be the most exciting -- and fairest -- points scoring system. It's also the simplest. They award points for the first 20 places, with 20 points for first place, decreasing by 1 point for each place, so that 20th place gets 1 point. This simple system has two tremendous benefits: It encourages and boosts the morale of less successful teams, because such teams can compete among themselves; It makes the championship results much closer and therefore more exciting for the fans.
Here's a comparison of the 2011 F1 season results for the first 11 races, to illustrate the differences between the current 25-point system and the simple 20-point system:
Driver --------- 25 Points -- Position -- 20 Points -- Position
Vettel ---------------- 216 ------- 1 ---------- 194 ------- 1
Webber --------------- 139 ------- 2 ---------- 176 ------- 2
Hamilton -------------- 134 ------- 3 ---------- 157 ------- 3
Alonso ---------------- 130 ------- 4 ---------- 157 ------- 4
Button ---------------- 109 ------- 5 ---------- 137 ------- 5
Massa ------------------ 62 ------- 6 ---------- 118 ------- 6
Rosberg ---------------- 46 ------- 7 ---------- 118 ------- 7
Heidfeld ---------------- 34 ------- 8 ---------- 100 ------- 8
Petrov ----------------- 32 ------- 9 ------------ 99 ------- 9
Schumacher ------------ 32 ------ 10 ----------- 95 ------- 10
Kobayashi -------------- 27 ------ 11 ----------- 94 ------- 12
Sutil ------------------- 18 ------- 12 ----------- 95 ------- 11
Alguersuari -------------- 9 ------- 13 ----------- 73 ------- 15
Perez ------------------- 8 ------- 14 ----------- 57 ------- 17
Buemi ------------------- 8 ------- 15 ----------- 83 ------- 13
Barrichello --------------- 4 ------- 16 ----------- 59 ------- 16
di Resta ----------------- 2 ------- 17 ----------- 74 ------- 14
de la Rosa --------------- 0 ------- 18 ------------ 9 ------- 24
Trulli -------------------- 0 ------- 19 ----------- 30 ------- 19
Liuzzi -------------------- 0 ------- 20 ---------- 16 -------- 23
Maldonado --------------- 0 ------- 21 ----------- 33 ------- 18
d'Ambrosio --------------- 0 ------- 22 ----------- 30 ------- 20
Kovalainen --------------- 0 ------- 23 ----------- 22 ------- 21
Glock -------------------- 0 ------- 24 ----------- 22 ------- 22
Karthikeyan -------------- 0 ------- 25 ------------ 8 -------- 25
Ricciardo ---------------- 0 ------- 26 ------------ 4 -------- 26
Chandhok ---------------- 0 ------- 27 ------------ 1 -------- 27
With the 20-point system, you can see that, if Vettel were to drop out of only one race and Webber were to finish first or second, Webber would overtake Vettel as the championship leader. Hamilton and Alonso would be only two race wins behind Vettel. Although the first 10 positions are no different, as is fair, the remaining driver championship positions are altered radically, and reward less successful drivers commensurately to their performance.
Surely Bernie Ecclestone will see that the present Formula One points scoring system is seriously flawed before long. It'll be interesting to see whether it'll be changed for 2012, in the light of the 2011 results. It's just a pity that no one in the organization had the intelligence, foresight or courage to mention it to him before the 2010 season started.
Read the latest sports news at the Morny Stannit online newspaper
S Avery.
Source: EzineArticles.com
The Monte-Carlo Option Pricing Formula
The Monte-Carlo Option Pricing Formula. By Scott E McClelland born April 13th 1909 in Lwow, Galicia, then in Austria - Hungary. Von Neumann is " generally regarded as one of the foremost mathematicians of the 20th
Toyota Driver's View On The 2006 Hungarian Grand Prix
The Panasonic Toyota racing team is heading to Central Europe for the 2006 Hungarian The Hungarian F1 Grand Prix will take place in the capital city of Budapest, I'll be looking for a better finish in Hungary.
Formula One: Mexico wants to host Grand Prix
Mexico wants to host a Formula One Grand Prix. Felipe Massa is shown in Hungary. Mexico wants to once again host Formula One, as Grand Prix racing suddenly appears to be a hot commodity on this side of the Atlantic. Austin, Texas, expects to host the.
A Short Bio on Lewis Hamilton
Seemingly against the laws of Formula One racing nature, Hamilton was in control but he bounced right back with a strong win in Hungary.